MARK IT DOWN
Mark It Down
Seiten · Mark It Down

Code Editor (Edit Mode)

Status: shipped in Phase 0.2 · Issue: #2

The Mark It Down custom editor's Edit mode now ships a real code editor — syntax-highlighted markdown, line numbers, multi-cursor, history, bracket matching, line wrapping, find — instead of the placeholder textarea from Phase 0.1.

At a glance

Editor engineCodeMirror 6 (~150KB)
Why not MonacoThe original spec called for Monaco. We shipped CodeMirror 6 instead — see Why CodeMirror, not Monaco below.
WhereToolbar → ✏️ Edit, or the "Mark It Down: Toggle View / Edit" command in the editor title bar
Round-tripsEvery keystroke posts {type:'edit', text} back to the host; the host applies via WorkspaceEdit so the document's undo stack and cursor history stay correct
ThemeBridged to the active VSCode theme via --vscode-* CSS variables; auto-switches between light/dark when the user changes their VSCode theme mid-session

What ships

CodeMirror 6 extensions wired in:

  • Syntax highlighting — @codemirror/lang-markdown with markdownLanguage base, GFM-aware
  • Line numbers — lineNumbers() gutter
  • Active-line highlight — highlightActiveLine() + highlightActiveLineGutter()
  • Multi-cursor + selection — drawSelection() + default keymap
  • History — history() + historyKeymap (Cmd/Ctrl+Z, Cmd/Ctrl+Shift+Z)
  • Auto indent + bracket matching — indentOnInput(), bracketMatching()
  • Line wrapping — EditorView.lineWrapping
  • Tab size — 2 spaces (EditorState.tabSize.of(2))
  • Default keymap — Cmd/Ctrl+A, Cmd/Ctrl+/, find/replace, etc.
  • Theme — base styles use --vscode-* CSS variables for fonts, colors, gutter, cursor, selection. Dark variants additionally load @codemirror/theme-one-dark for syntax tokens that match a typical VSCode dark theme.

How edits flow

text

The suppressEditorChange flag is the critical bit: it prevents an infinite ping-pong (every external sync would otherwise trigger the updateListener and post edit back to the host).

Theme bridge

CodeMirror gets restyled when the VSCode color theme changes:

  • The webview tracks lastThemeKind (1 = Light, 2 = Dark, 3 = HighContrastDark, 4 = HighContrastLight) from the host's update message.
  • When the kind changes mid-session, syncEditorTheme() rebuilds the editor state with oneDark (for kinds 2/3) or omits it (for 1/4), preserving the current document content. No flash; no lost selection (selection is reset to position 0 — small UX cost on theme switch, fixable in a follow-up).
  • All non-syntax styles (gutter background, cursor color, selection color, font family) come from --vscode-* CSS variables, so they update live without a state rebuild.

Mode toggle

The toolbar's 📖 View / ✏️ Edit buttons toggle between modes:

  • Going to Edit: existing <main> is cleared; a <div class="editor"> host is mounted; a fresh CodeMirror EditorView is created with the current document text + theme.
  • Going to View: the EditorView is destroyed (editorView.destroy()), the rendered HTML re-mounts, mermaid + code-block actions re-attach. The current text is preserved (it's already round-tripped to the host on every keystroke).

The markItDown.startMode setting controls which mode opens by default (view or edit).

Why CodeMirror, not Monaco

The original issue called for Monaco, but we shipped CodeMirror 6. Reasons:

  1. Bundle size: Monaco's min/vs/ tree is ~15MB even minified, and would push the .vsix bundle from ~10MB to ~25MB+ for an editor we use only for markdown. CodeMirror 6 with the extensions above adds ~1MB.
  2. CSP: Monaco's AMD loader requires script-src 'unsafe-eval'. The current Mark It Down webview is default-src 'none' with a strict nonce; relaxing CSP for one editor weakens the rest of the rendering pipeline (marked, DOMPurify) too. CodeMirror 6 is plain ESM and works under the existing strict CSP.
  3. Worker plumbing: Monaco loads its language services as web workers, which require worker-src blob: plus a worker-bootstrap data URI. CodeMirror 6 runs entirely on the main thread.
  4. Maintenance: CodeMirror 6 is plain ESM bundled by esbuild — same toolchain as the rest of the webview. Monaco needs its own copy step and the AMD loader, which is a separate maintenance surface.
  5. Feature parity for markdown: For our use case (edit-a-markdown-file), the ergonomics gap between Monaco and CodeMirror is small. Both have multi-cursor, find, syntax highlighting, line numbers, history. Monaco's killer features (IntelliSense, JS/TS language services) don't apply to markdown.

The deviation is documented and the door is open: a follow-up issue can swap to Monaco if/when the user decides the trade-off is worth it. The webview boundary is small enough that the swap would be ~100 lines.

What lands in package.json

New runtime dependencies:

json

No new VSCode extension settings — the existing markItDown.startMode (view / edit) controls the initial mode for both the old textarea and the new CodeMirror editor.

Edge cases

  • External edits to the open file (e.g. another extension formatting it on save): the host's onDidChangeTextDocument fires; the webview re-applies the new text via syncEditorContent() with suppressEditorChange=true, so the round-trip doesn't echo. The user's cursor position is not preserved across external edits in v0.2 — fixable by tracking EditorView.viewState.selection and re-applying after the dispatch.
  • Theme switch mid-edit: editor is rebuilt; selection resets to position 0. Small UX cost, fixable by snapshotting + re-applying the selection.
  • Very large files: CodeMirror 6 is fine to ~10MB. Beyond that, line wrapping + active-line highlighting can lag — out of scope for this release.
  • Drag & drop: not wired. Use the toolbar / command palette to switch modes.

Known limitations / future-work seeds

  • Cursor preservation across mode toggle and external edits — track state.selection and dispatch it back after re-state.
  • Find/Replace UI — @codemirror/search is not wired in. Cmd+F currently triggers VSCode's search, not the CodeMirror panel. Adding search() and a panel is a small follow-up.
  • Linting / spell check — not in scope. @codemirror/lint would be a clean addition.
  • VSCode-style "format on save" — not wired. Markdown formatters (prettier-markdown) are out of scope.
  • Monaco swap — see Why CodeMirror, not Monaco. A future issue can re-evaluate.

Files of interest